Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Anna Krylov's avatar

These books are timely and important. Despite the often-expressed sentiment, the pendulum is still going strong on campuses. I do not see it swinging back. The postmodern rot -- as exemplified by (but not limited to) gender studies -- continues unabated. Strong action is needed -- we need to close epistemically bankrupt departments and programs.

Jenny Poyer Ackerman's avatar

I’ll order both as soon as I post this note! After studying gender ideology for a decade (as an interested civilian, not a scholar) it’s clear that publishers have actively colluded in the suppression of debate — thus knowledge. So I’m very encouraged to see these books break through on the heels of Andy Gno’s new one on the Zizian trans death cult (Hachette, no less!) plus 3 coming next year from Lisa Selin Davis, Jesse Singal and Sarah Mittermeier. More conspicuous now is the continued capture of The New Yorker and its ilk. I think it boils down to the cowardice of celebrity magazine and newspaper editors (e.g., David Remnick) whose names we all know vs book publishing ‘houses,’ whose decision makers have the luxury of being more anonymous. Whether or not I’m right about that, the lopsided result has been that only the most motivated readers have found anything ‘controversial’ that’s useful to read.

24 more comments...

Ready for more?