26 Comments
User's avatar
Anna Krylov's avatar

These books are timely and important. Despite the often-expressed sentiment, the pendulum is still going strong on campuses. I do not see it swinging back. The postmodern rot -- as exemplified by (but not limited to) gender studies -- continues unabated. Strong action is needed -- we need to close epistemically bankrupt departments and programs.

JGB's avatar
Oct 29Edited

I find more and more students can see through this stuff. One notable example was a High School student (taking college classes) remarked "Diversity is only skin deep." Plus, underserved students are starting to resent the condescending implications of DEI.

It gets worse.

For half a century Education painted itself as the great equalizer that will lift underserved communities. Sadly, educators do not live up to that - rather than teaching skills for success, they teach excuses for failure. Disadvantaged children get this non-education while children of privilege have the option of going to a good Private School or supplementing Public School with tutors and after-school programs. Ironically, Public Schools are reinforcing their disadvantage while acting like their saviors.

There have already been some lawsuits brought by students against schools for failure to actually teach - more are coming.

Andreas Bikfalvi's avatar

My very timely book « science under influence » will come out on November 20. This is the French version, but an English version is in preparation . The book digs deeply into epistemic issues as well as on moralization and politicization. A useful synthesis about the whole problem.

J Chicago's avatar

Ok, here's a suggestion that I'm sure could be improved. A lot of the bad scholarship I read employs known logical fallacies--ad hominem arguments, straw men, claims of authority based on things which are irrelevant, etc.

Could one take all the theses or maybe papers in each department and find out how many of the claims are poorly argued--would this be possible using AI?

Can one train an AI to distinguish obscure sophistry from clear arguments?

Alexander Simonelis's avatar

Rx: Courage

The rest is common sense and easy. Courage is hard.

Jenny Poyer Ackerman's avatar

I’ll order both as soon as I post this note! After studying gender ideology for a decade (as an interested civilian, not a scholar) it’s clear that publishers have actively colluded in the suppression of debate — thus knowledge. So I’m very encouraged to see these books break through on the heels of Andy Gno’s new one on the Zizian trans death cult (Hachette, no less!) plus 3 coming next year from Lisa Selin Davis, Jesse Singal and Sarah Mittermeier. More conspicuous now is the continued capture of The New Yorker and its ilk. I think it boils down to the cowardice of celebrity magazine and newspaper editors (e.g., David Remnick) whose names we all know vs book publishing ‘houses,’ whose decision makers have the luxury of being more anonymous. Whether or not I’m right about that, the lopsided result has been that only the most motivated readers have found anything ‘controversial’ that’s useful to read.

Laurie Winogrand's avatar

David Remnick's oily contempt for anyone who doesn't tow the woke party line in interviews is disgustingly transparent. He drips with it. I have had a hard time listening to any of his interviews since I heard his undeserved skewering of Robert F Kennedy Jr. on NPR's New Yorker Radio Hour when Bobby was running for President. Remnick's brain is so captured he has no realistic perspective on himself or his interview subjects. This tunnel vision capture is endemic to the progressive left, the gender mafia, etc.

JGB's avatar

I teach STEM at a Community College in California. Our school is a hotbed of Social Justice activism and all employees are required to do regular acts of social justice. Doubly so for me: I am a Straight White Male, and thus am always under suspicion of nefarious deeds (like running a secret slave plantation). To avoid being tossed into a gulag, I invest minimum time & effort in social causes (Da Da Tovarich Kommisar) - but I put my real creative energy into outside projects free of meddlesome ideology.

Those outside organizations appreciate my humble efforts supporting them and it feels nice to be appreciated. It is not just me - increasingly STEM professionals prefer to work in private industry or at national labs rather than Universities - they seek intellectual freedom.

It puts me in mind of the History of Physics in the early 20th century: Germany was the center of Modern Physics (e.g. Quantum Mechanics & Relativity). Many big names in Physics of the era were German Jews - when the Nazis came to power and started oppressing the Jews the Jewish scientists did not stop doing Physics, instead, they left Germany and did Physics at freer Nations... which became Germany's enemies.

Note: I compared Academia to _both_ Nazi Germany and Soviet Russia.

Elizabeth Moorchild's avatar

I escaped the CA community college system for this reason. I wanted to teach creative and critical thinking, not dogmatic chatecisms.

J Chicago's avatar

The nonsense words are having material and harmful effects in medicine, where literally thousands of minors in the US, every year, are being started on medical gender interventions with serious lifelong consequences (Reuters, https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-transyouth-care/ ). Medical societies and journals (i.e, scholarly medical research journals) and clinicians are too afraid to question the treatments because medical gender interventions have become tangled up with untouchable questions related to identity pushed by these academics. Parents who try to question the treatments are treated as villains by schools, doctors, and even the law in many states.

At this point, the clinicians can't even agree what they are aiming to treat, originally it was to relieve distress and prevent suicides, but that has not been borne out by studies (partially the studies are so poorly done nothing can be concluded, nonetheless these interventions are being provided at first visit, for instance at Boston Children's hospital, https://www.bostonglobe.com/2024/11/01/metro/gender-affirming-care-trans-boston-childrens-hospital/ ). Now it is all about "autonomy"--a great argument for removing functioning body parts of a teen not even old enough to legally get a tattoo or smoke or drink... https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13660275/ .

Anyone who tries to speak up (including many excellent reporters, such as Jesse Singal, Pamela Paul, Lisa Selin Davis, Ben Ryan) is shown the door, or allowed to speak, but only tiny tiny amounts. UK reporters like Hannah Barnes, Jennifer Block and Nick Wallis are covering it also, again with headwinds.

The harm discussed in the two books here to the universities and the future its students will create is huge. The harm to the bodies of these children is also terrible. They have the rest of their lives (60 years? more?) to wake up to it, every day.

Elizabeth Moorchild's avatar

Yes. Also on the list of those brutalized by this nonsense are the women locked in jail cells with male murderers and rapists. Cruel and unusual punishment.

Lisa Simeone's avatar

J Chicago: exactly. Have restacked your comment.

Someday there will be a reckoning. Someday, when this "trans" fever finally breaks, all the people who’ve aided and abetted this grotesquerie, this criminal cult, will try to go crawling quietly back into the woodwork, hoping the rest of us will forget. But we won’t. We won’t forget. And I, for one, will shove it in their faces every chance I get.

J Chicago's avatar

Those who were badly harmed will not be able to forget.

MMP's avatar

Great article. Very informative. But I must ask- what took so long for these authors to come to these conclusions and finally write about it? The university has been in free fall for decades exacerbated by covid and George Floyd.

J Chicago's avatar

The article by Haidt that is referenced in there is from way back, and gets it all right, it seems to me! https://heterodoxacademy.org/blog/one-telos-truth-or-social-justice-2/

Jake Wiskerchen's avatar

It very hard to leave a cult...or in this case, cultlike systems.

JGB's avatar

Especially a vindictive cult that punishes apostasy.

Sadhana Stupar's avatar

some of us have been talking about these issues for a long time. 2015 was a real turning point, when social justice/neo-Marxism really took over our universities. It's been difficult what with 'cancellation' and people losing their jobs for speaking up. That alone speaks volumes about what has been happening in the past 10+ years. More recently enough people have been speaking out and a "counter-revolution" has begun pushing back. Now accusations of racism and the latest phobia-du-jour are being seen as what they are: a hollow means of trying to shut down discussion and defuse any rebuttals to such one-sided thinking/ideologies.

SlowlyReading's avatar

Excellent, thank you! I hope that Mr. Dudley doesn't get fired or brought before a disciplinary tribunal for writing this review. Old-timers will remember that it was a decade ago now that the now-notorious Jordan Peterson was brought up on charges by the Canadian Ulama for questioning the woke gender hadiths. That was a bad sign, but only disreputable and disagreeable people were willing to say so at the time.

Sweet Caroline's avatar

I was horrified to discover the gender studies classes that I paid for at my daughter’s woke University. They sealed the deal on her indoctrination before I even knew this was a thing. Her favorite class? Gender and Geography. What the hell is that? I’m a fool for giving them my hard earned money as well as my daughter.

Richard Bicker's avatar

See the recent reports on the Mellon Foundation and its substantial support ($$$) of rabid DEI and other "social justice" malarkey at colleges and non-profit organizations all over the country. Its current president was spun up in the Ford Foundation's racial justice department before moving on to bigger and better (and more destructive) things. Vile people backed by incredible resources; NOT a good mix.

Doingmybest's avatar

I Just Disagree there's been political Orthodoxy far beyond any of this. And there's a lot of assholes that say that empathy is a flaw. Those are too broad and saying gender ideology is just a red flag and a whistle blow at that point. So obvious that's even the humans can hear it. However we only got here because views were suppressed.

Mark Stocker's avatar

All this sounds perfectly plausible to me. My one caveat is that when I politely suggested to one of the (better say unnamed) anthology contributors that he banged on a bit less about Gaza, all but supporting the evil Israeli government, and instead focussed on what he was qualified to do, exposing shoddy and PC science, his reply was so vituperative that I reported him to his university authorities and said he was abusing his emeritus status. They sympathised but felt they couldn't really intervene. Just saying!

((( Moishe the Beadle )))'s avatar

It's ironic that Sullivan has been captured by a segment of that ideological movement himself. He's absorbed the anti Israel libel, that has been inserted into academia by billions poured into the Universities by Qatar.